Consider three common scenarios. An employee discovers that payroll never implemented their deferred compensation election. An agency negotiates a new employer contribution without realizing that some employees already contribute the annual maximum. An employee retires expecting to defer their accumulated vacation payout, only to learn that they submitted the election too late.
These situations can leave public agencies facing unexpected costs, employee complaints, and retirement plan compliance problems. Although many agencies rely on third-party administrators to manage their Section 457(b) plans, the underlying mistakes often stem from payroll practices or employer decisions.
Correcting these errors is also challenging. The IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS) offers established correction methods for 401(k) and 403(b) plans, but it does not cover governmental Section 457(b) plans.
1. Missed Employee Deferrals: Can the Agency Make the Employee Whole?
An employee elects to contribute $100 per paycheck to the agency’s Section 457(b) plan, but payroll never implements the election. Two years later, the employee discovers that no contributions were made.
The employee has already received the compensation that should have been deferred and has lost the opportunity to invest those contributions. The agency cannot simply withhold two years of missed deferrals from a future paycheck and treat them as contributions for the earlier years.
An employer-funded corrective contribution may be appropriate to compensate the employee for the missed deferral opportunity and associated investment earnings. However, the IRS has not prescribed a missed-deferral correction formula for governmental Section 457(b) plans comparable to those available under EPCRS.
The agency must determine an appropriate corrective contribution and whether the applicable contribution limits allow it. This becomes particularly difficult when the employee already contributes the maximum amount or when the missed deferrals relate to prior tax years.
Before agreeing to a corrective payment, the agency should calculate the missed deferrals, identify the affected years, and confirm that the plan can accept the contribution. If the limits prevent the proposed correction, the agency will need to evaluate other legally available remedies rather than simply depositing the missed amounts.
2. Employer Contributions: When an MOU Promises More Than the Plan Can Accept
Public agencies frequently negotiate employer contributions to Section 457(b) plans through memoranda of understanding (MOUs) or individual employment agreements. A fixed employer contribution can become problematic when employees also make elective deferrals.
For 2026, the basic annual Section 457(b) contribution limit is $24,500. Both employee deferrals and vested employer contributions count toward that limit, although eligible employees may qualify for additional catch-up contributions.
Suppose an MOU requires an agency to contribute $1,500 annually to an employee’s Section 457(b) account. The employee has already elected to defer the maximum permissible amount. The agency cannot simply add another $1,500 to the account without exceeding the federal limit.
The problem is that the agency has negotiated a benefit it may be unable to provide in the promised form. Reducing the employee’s elective deferrals may resolve the contribution limit issue prospectively, but the agency cannot unilaterally disregard its obligations under the MOU.
If the agency has already made excess contributions, Treasury Regulation Section 1.457-4(e)(2) requires the plan to distribute the excess deferrals, together with allocable earnings, as soon as administratively practicable after it identifies the excess. Failure to make the required distribution can cost the plan its eligible status and create adverse tax consequences for participants.
For future agreements, agencies can avoid this conflict by addressing how employer contributions will be handled when an employee reaches the applicable Section 457(b) limit. Depending on the negotiated arrangement, this could include reducing elective deferrals or providing an alternative benefit that does not violate federal tax requirements.
3. Accumulated Leave Payouts: Why the Election Deadline Matters
Employees retiring from public service often receive significant accumulated vacation or sick leave payouts. Some seek to defer these payments into their Section 457(b) accounts to avoid recognizing the entire amount as taxable income in the year of retirement.
Federal tax rules permit certain accumulated leave payments to be deferred, including qualifying payments made after separation from employment. However, the employee must make a valid election before the applicable deadline.
Under Treasury Regulation Section 1.457-4(d), an employee ordinarily must make the election before the beginning of the month in which the agency pays the compensation or makes it available, subject to the regulation’s specific rules.
An employee who waits until the final payroll is being processed may have already missed that deadline. The agency cannot fix the problem by backdating the election or treating a late election as timely.
This is one reason retirement paperwork should address deferred compensation elections well before an employee’s final paycheck. Payroll and benefits staff should confirm the amount of the anticipated leave payout, the employee’s remaining contribution capacity, and the election deadline before processing the payment.
4. Plan Documents: When Negotiated Benefits Were Never Added to the Plan
An agency may properly negotiate a new deferred compensation benefit but fail to amend its Section 457(b) plan document to reflect the agreement.
The agency then faces a problem that it cannot necessarily resolve by pointing to the MOU. The written retirement plan must satisfy federal tax requirements, and the agency must administer contributions consistently with the plan’s terms.
If the agency has been making contributions that the plan does not authorize, it must determine whether a plan amendment is permissible and whether the contributions already made require separate correction.
A retroactive amendment cannot simply override federal contribution limits or validate deferral elections that employees made after the applicable deadline. Nor does an amendment automatically resolve every past operational failure.
When negotiating new retirement benefits, the agency should review the plan document before implementing the contribution. If the MOU and plan document already conflict, the agency will need to address both its contractual obligations and the plan’s tax compliance.
5. Correcting Errors
Governmental Section 457(b) plans have a correction framework under Section 457(b)(6) and Treasury Regulation Section 1.457-9(a). These provisions allow a governmental plan to preserve its eligible status by correcting specified failures before the first day of the plan year beginning more than 180 days after the IRS gives written notification to correct a plan error.
Agencies do not need to wait for IRS notification to correct errors. The IRS recognizes that governmental Section 457(b) sponsors can voluntarily self-correct failures to comply with federal tax requirements.
For certain operational failures, an agency may also request a voluntary closing agreement with the IRS. The IRS has discretion to accept or reject these requests and does not use that process to resolve defects in written plan documents.
In practice, the correction process begins with identifying the affected employees and tax years, calculating the amounts involved, and determining whether the plan and federal contribution limits permit the proposed correction. If the agency incorrectly reported contributions or distributions, it may also need to address payroll tax reporting.
Addressing Errors Before They Spread
The cost of a Section 457(b) mistake is not always limited to the original contribution. An agency may also need to address lost investment earnings, incorrect tax reporting, or an MOU obligation that the plan cannot fulfill.
Once an error is discovered, the priority should be to stop the incorrect practice, determine how far back it extends, and implement a correction that does not create another violation. Waiting until an employee retires or a plan audit identifies the problem can leave the agency with fewer practical options.







